Skip to Content

21 Delicious Recipes for Pudding Pops

21 Delicious Recipes for Pudding Pops, including Reeses, butterscotch, chocolate, strawberry, peach cobbler, limoncello, banana and many more!

pudding pops collage

Favorite Pudding Pop Recipes

We all know that kids love their popsicles. But my feeling is… what about the adults? We love our popsicles too! There’s nothing better than devouring a dripping popsicle on a sweltering hot day.

Pudding pops are a bit different. They’re frozen, and they melt. But the consistency is thicker, so they melt in slower form. And because they’re made with pudding, they’re creamy and wonderful. And you can be as creative as you want with additions. Here’s a round-up of the best pudding pop recipes. Print out your favorites, and make them at home for the hot days ahead.

four reeses pudding pops on plate

Reeses Pudding Pops by Recipe Boy: We especially like popsicles that have candy in them. Pudding and candy all frozen together in a popsicle does sound rather dreamy, doesn’t it?

banana pudding pops displayed with nilla wafers

Banana Pudding Pops by Crayons and Cravings: Whether you are looking for an ice-cold dessert to enjoy or a new banana dessert to make, you are going to love these yummy banana popsicles.

banana split pudding pops in bowl

Banana Split Pudding Pops by The Recipe Rebel: In these pops, there are 3 layers of creamy, frozen pudding: strawberry, banana pineapple and chocolate! It’s an easy way to enjoy a banana split!

two stacked blueberry lemon pudding pops with lemon slices

Blueberry Lemon Pudding Pops by Super Healthy Kids: These creamy dreamy pudding pops have a refreshing tart lemon flavor, and they are packed with fresh blueberries

funfetti pudding pop

Funfetti Pudding Pops by Rachel Cooks: Easy to make, festive, and fun, these pops are a fun treat for the whole family. Kids especially love these!

lemon blueberry pudding pops

Lemon Blueberry Pudding Pops by Wonky Wonderful: These are a quick and easy afternoon snack for the kids.

limoncello pudding pops on ice

Limoncello Pudding Pops by I’m Bored, Let’s Go: Instead of an icy popsicle, these pops are creamy, like a fudgsicle.

marshmallow fruity pebble pops on ice

Marshmallow Fruity Pebbles Pudding Pops by Live Well, Bake Often: Not only are these pops ridiculously easy to make, but they’re also filled with such gorgeous colors from the cereal.

stack of peach cobbler pudding pops

Peach Cobbler Pudding Pops by Will Cook for Smiles: These fantastic pudding pops are filled with fresh peaches and snickerdoodle cookies to make them taste just like peach cobbler.

caramel frappuccino pudding pops in bowl of ice

Caramel Frappuccino Pudding Pops by Inside BruCrew Life: The coffee and caramel blend in these popsicles will give you the boost you need to get through the day!

basket of red white and blue pudding pops

Red, White and Blue Pudding Pops by Life in the Lofthouse: These pops have a patriotic look to them!

chia coconut pudding pop upside down

Chia Coconut Pudding Popsicles by The View From Great Island: A refreshingly delicious and healthy way to start the day, these non-dairy, vegan breakfast popsicles are worth getting out of bed for!

chocolate banana pudding pop

Chocolate Banana Pudding Pops by Semi Homemade Recipes: Layers of chocolate pudding and banana pudding make up these fun, homemade frozen pops.

hand holding spumoni pudding pop

Spumoni Jello Pudding Pops by Crafty Cooking Mama: These pops are made with pistachio pudding, chocolate, cherries and nuts.

chocolate pudding pops laid on surface

Chocolate Pudding Pops by Love & Lemons: Creamy from avocado and almond butter, these healthy treats are perfect on hot summer days.

stacked strawberry cheesecake pudding pops

Strawberry Cheesecake Pudding Pops by Thirty Handmade Days: The perfect summer treat, these pops are so easy to make and they taste amazing.

coconut vanilla pudding pops

Coconut Vanilla Pudding Pops by Yummy Healthy Easy: These pops are creamy with a tropical coconut punch. They’re just plain addictive. 

cookies and cream pudding pops laid on surface

Cookies and Cream Pudding Pops by Creme de la Crumb: These pops are made with just 5 ingredients, and they are jam-packed full of chocolatey Oreo and cookies-n-cream goodness.

fresh strawberry and vanilla pudding pops laid on table

Fresh Strawberry and Vanilla Pudding Pops by Maebells: These pops are made with fresh berries, instant vanilla pudding mix, and milk. They’re so refreshing on a hot day! 

stacked tropical pudding pops

Tropical Pudding Pops by Or Whatever You Do: Fresh fruit and instant pudding are a perfect match in this awesome summer treat. 

butterscotch pudding pops stacked

Butterscotch Pudding Pops by Smitten Kitchen: These pops are thick and creamy (rather than icy and drippy), they taste like dreamy butterscotch and the sweetness does not overwhelm.