This post may contain affiliate links, and I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read our privacy policy.
The time for stuffing something inside of an Oreo has come again. Remember our chocolate chip cookie dough stuffed Oreos? We made Chocolate Dipped Peanut Butter Cup Stuffed Oreos. There is a video in the post showing you how to make this recipe, and then you can scroll all the way to the bottom of this post and print out the recipe so you can make these at home.
Chocolate-Dipped Peanut Butter Stuffed Oreos
RecipeBoy Brooks first made these way back in 2012. We had seen these treats in a candy shop, and we went home and made them. It was such an easy treat to make, so this is a fun one to make with your kids!
🛒 Ingredients Needed:
- Double Stuff Oreos (you can use the golden Oreos, if you’d like!)
- Reeses Peanut Butter Cups
- Milk Chocolate Chips (or any other kind of chocolate)
- butter (or shortening)
You’ll begin by slicing the Oreos in half. As you slice an Oreo in half, keep the sides with the cream for these Chocolate Dipped Peanut Butter Cup Stuffed Oreos. The other sides can be kept in a zip baggie in the freezer and saved for future Oreo pie crusts and other goodies!
✏️ How to Make Chocolate Dipped Peanut Butter Cup Stuffed Oreos:
- STEP 1: Place the Oreo half with the cream on a cutting board.
- STEP 2: Place a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup on top.
- STEP 3: Put another Oreo half with the cream on top and press down gently.
- STEP 4: Dip the treat in melted chocolate combined with melted butter. (Be sure to cover the whole thing in chocolate!)
- STEP 5: Remove the treat from the chocolate with a fork and set it on a baking sheet that has been lined with a silpat mat or parchment paper to let the chocolate harden.
- STEP 6: Scatter some sprinkles on top of the Chocolate- Dipped Peanut Butter Cup Stuffed Oreos. You can choose whatever color or colors you want.
❤️ What We Love About This Recipe
- Each bite combines the rich, creamy taste of peanut butter with the sweet indulgence of chocolate and the classic crunch of an Oreo cookie. It’s a flavor explosion in your mouth!
- The marriage of sweet chocolate and salty peanut butter strikes the perfect balance, satisfying your cravings for both salty and sweet treats in one delicious bite.
- These treats are not only tasty but are also visually stunning. The glossy chocolate coating, the peek of peanut butter cup inside, and the familiar Oreo pattern make them irresistible.
Here are a few more Oreo-inspired recipes you might enjoy:
Chocolate Dipped Peanut Butter Cup Stuffed Oreos
Ingredients
- 16 Double Stuf Oreos
- 8 regular-sized Reeses Peanut Butter Cups, unwrapped
- 1½ cups milk chocolate chips
- 1 teaspoon butter
Instructions
- Slice each Oreo in half, careful to keep the cream filling on one half. Keep the cream sides and put the chocolate wafer sides into a zip bag. You can keep those in the freezer for making a future chocolate cookie pie crust. You will end up with 16 Oreo halves with cream filling.
- Set an Oreo half on your work surface (cream side up). Top it with a peanut butter cup. Then set another Oreo half on top (cream side down) of the peanut butter cup and gently press down. Repeat with the remaining ingredients until you have 8 cookie sandwiches.
- Melt the chocolate chips with the butter- either in the microwave or in a pan over low heat- until smooth. Use a fork to dip a sandwich treat into the melted chocolate and cover it completely with chocolate. Gently shake off the dripping chocolate, and then set it onto waxed paper or a baking mat. Sprinkle colorful sprinkles on top. Repeat with all of the treats. Refrigerate the treats until the chocolate is set. We kept our treats stored in a covered container in the refrigerator for cool munching on a summer day!
Nutrition
This recipe comes from RecipeBoy.com
I’m currently expecting a baby as well, so I can tell you from personal experience that these genius creations are a pregnant woman’s dream-come-true! Fantastic combination of decadent treats to create a true indulgence =).
What a fantastic recipe! I would so love to try some. They look awesome!
These looks totally decadent! You’ve combined two of my favorite treats into complete awesomeness.
Brooks – you’ve got it going on with these! They look fantabulous!
My hubby would be over the moon excited to eat these lol. Two of his favorite things combined into 1 treat! Great choice for Jenny’s baby shower too! We all know she loves Oreos, hee hee.
Love the picture of it sliced in half with all of the layers showing!
Brooks! I’m so impressed! What a tasty looking dessert, amazing photography and writing you’ve done. Awesome all around!
Wow!!! Recipe Boy, thanks for making such a sweet treat for me today!! You and your mom are so great! Have a great day!!
These look oh so good!!! Mmmm….
These look unreal! Your blog is so inspiring 🙂
These are very impressive mister… and they look super tasty too!
What a fun treat!
these are intense! they look amazing!
That fact that you made these for Jenny – you are such a sweetheart! And boy, they look amazing! I wish I had a few of them of my own. Love the sprinkles on top, too!
Ooo…Brooks! Those look AMAZING…and anything with Oreos is perfect for Jenny!
Wow, that looks amazing!! I want 6!!
How cool are these??! What an incredibly sweet, decadent treat! Love these, RecipeBoy!! 🙂
this recipe is too good to be true! yum!
What a perfect treat for Jenny- oreos + peanut butter, total winner for her.
These look fantastic!
These are so creative, Brooks! They look awesome and I’ll bet they tasted even better. 🙂
These look out of this world… Love the creativity. I could definitely eat a few of these… YUM!
Oh man I thing you’ve come up with the ultimate treat RecipeBoy!! My family would LOVE to hep you finish these off……or need some recipe tasters!!
These are such a great treat! Super job!
These are so perfect I HAD to pin them twice. The perfect tribute to Jenny ~ so thrilled you could join us 🙂
There are no words.
I am speechless, and as my husband will tell you… that’s a serious accomplishment.
My kids are going to flip their lids over these! Great recipe, Recipe Boy!
These look so rich and delicious,so creative!
This is unreal! So creative. Talk about sugar overload!
Wow! They look absolutely gorgeous! Such an inspiration! Thanks!
omGoodness! that sounds like heaven! i just bought ing to make the cookie dough stuffed oreoes. now i may just buy some reese cups too. you rock, recipeBoy!
Wow!! I think I could find a home for these… 🙂
Way to go putting two awesome things together! I’ve had chocolate covered Oreos before, but there are so much better!
Whoah… These look really good! I’m not so much into sweet stuff, by these are great to look at and to eat, I’m sure. Great pictures, I love the colors.
These are a must have!
What an awesome treat!! I’ll have to make this as a surprise for my kiddos after school one day.
Your Mom and I must be kindred spirits! These look AMAZING! I’ll think about the calories the day after I gorge on these! LOL!
This is just the perfect recipe! My three favorite treats in one 🙂 Can not wait to make em then eat em!
A bit messy to make, it’s easy to keep the oreo top on when the Reese is crush down then put on the top. Over all tastes awesome!
These look amazing, and the other creations from the babyshower Oh My Gosh YUM
Recipe was very yummy but I think the preparing the melted chocolate part of the directions was lacking explation and should be more detailed. Otherwise it was great!
Having a sleep over tonight and making ’em!
can’t wait…don’t think the kids are going to sleep at all!!
You. In my mouth. Now.
I love the Oreo cookie surprise it looks, smells, and taste good
Yum !! I made it, loved it, and translated it into French to use on my blog (linking your website).
Thanks !!
My son made these with me….he used small candy stars and wrote a P on one, an R on the next and so on to ask his girlfriend to the prom and gave it to her during a dinner with her parents:)
I read about you today in my News Journal (Wilmington Delaware) Sunday paper’s USA WEEKEND section. I love your website and recipes. I am going to let my 10 year old granddaughter and 12 year old grandson know about it. They live in suburban Los Angeles and my granddaughter is just starting to learn to cook. I’ve Bookmarked your site so I can check it often.
I made these loved them fantastic but my siblings though they were too sweet
How did you cut them in half so perfectly?
I really don’t know… 🙂
Love the idea–going to make this for my daughters baby shower.
The 1 1/2 cups milk chocolate chips & 1 teaspoon butter did NOT work for us – the chocolate chips were not melting and once it did – it was burning. This was the best solution for us – use Almond bark, heat over low flame and mix with a wooden spoon 6-7 minutes – worked great; everyone loved the treats.
These look amazing! You should use the Reese’s peanut butter and chocolate filling oreos!
Would they taste good with white chocolate as well?
sure!
I tried these, but every cookie seemed to break in half. Or it would break while in the chocolate. What on earth should I do differently?
You just have to be very gentle!
This is such a cute idea! Perfect for Christmas ♥
I made these today to bring to a Father’s day picnic!! They turned out perfectly!! Everyone loved them! Thank you!!
The kids know to save their Halloween pb cups to make this delicacy! So good!
Can these be made before time n put in the freezer?
Maybe!